Cover of Shouldn't Have Come: A Four Horsemen Dark Why Choose Romance

free

Shouldn't Have Come: A Four Horsemen Dark Why Choose Romance

by Sloane Sabel

Available for 4 days. Available until 10/19/2026.

Shouldn’t Have Come merges Her Soul to Take with The Four Horsemen series by Laura Thalassa into a horror romance set in a haunted motel. The harbingers are hot, deadly, and queer, the heroine won’t choose, and everybody wins at the end… well, mostly. This is a paranormal dark monster romance dripping with depravity and spice. It is very smutty and strictly for adults—please check the Reader’s Advisory before reading. What happens when a void witch who has nothing left to lose accidentally summons the four horsemen who are all monsters? Well, she can either submit, fight, or fall... Valeria is feared for her magic, and it's bad for business. When she gets a big offer, a séance on live tv during a full moon, she can't resist. Ignoring the red flags, she's determined to be seen, to be heard. But when the ritual goes to shit and the four horsemen are unleashed and she's forced into a corner. They want her, exactly as she is, to be theirs. People are dying and Valeria needs to make her choice. Who does she choose to save? This book features pansexual and non-binary rep, themes of mental illness, bullying, and, above all, self-acceptance. The spice is depraved, the aftercare is real, and the HEA is well-earned.